We were blown away by the value for money. Our room, pumpkin patch, had extremely soft carpets and we loved the private bathroom. The towels were so soft and thick. The AC unit cooled down the room nicely. I’m not typically a fan of bed and breakfasts but this one was so great. The morning breakfast was incredible - and private/isolated if you want it to be. Overall, we loved our stay.

Nothing to think of

The innkeeper was most accommodating, even to the point of coming and letting us in when we accidently locked the key in the room. Breakfast choices were good and tasty. Room was immaculately clean. Provided good advice on restaurants. Seemed concerned for our comfort. We were comfortable and slept well.

B& B is on fairly busy state highway. On the somewhat expensive side for what was offered, but it seems that that particular weekend was overbooked in the whole region. Room was simply, but adequate.

We enjoyed each breakfast and the size and cleanliness of the room. The location was close enough to the places we wanted to visit. Even though it is a bed and breakfast, Tin Brook doesn't feel like you are living in someone's house since it has private entrance and private bath.

No bed and pillow combo is as comfortable as my one at home.

Charming decor in this beautifully appointed room. Every detail was thought of in order to make the stay comfortable. Exceptionally clean room with thick plush towels. Hot clean shower and quality soap and shampoo. David, the owner was very kind and informative. Breakfast was delicious too!

Mattress was a little saggy, would consider replacing.

Absolutely delightful host, David - friendly, helpful, fun... Breakfast was served in a gift store - bizarre, but something you will remember with a smile...

We came to Catskills for hiking, and the closest park (Minewaska National Park) was closed due to forest fires. And the next good place for hiking was over an hour drive away! The bed's comfort was so-so ( mm... yes, I've slept on worse beds) - but - the pillows! Who on earth came up with the idea to make bed pillows LIKE THAT? They should be used in high security prisons for punishment...

Lovely bed & break, very clean and comfortable bed. Excellent breakfast and well decorated with Halloween decorations. Lovely shop attached to the bed & breakfast! Staff very welcoming.

The only thing I could says was the bathroom was separate from the bedroom but it was still private.

I liked the man who owned the B&B… he was genuine and made us feel at home. I also liked the little gift shop there…this isn’t a fancy place - just one that makes you feel comfortable and welcomed.

Quaint location and our Apple suite was like brand new and spacious and the bed was so comfy. The gift shop and where you have breakfast was great and David and his mom make a very nice breakfast!

Na

We stayed in the Strawberry Room, above the gift shop. It was spacious, included a love seat, breakfast table & 2 chairs, king bed, and a mini-frig. with a true freezer. (There is no ice available.) The woman who made breakfast for us in the gift shop is a precious soul, & she makes great French toast! There were 4 tables in the gift shop for B&B guests that were well spaced out. (Breakfast was served before the gift shop opened at 10:00.)

An alarm clock would really have been helpful, & microwave would have been nice but not essential. The tall, wooden, exterior stairway is very sturdy but has only a wide, flat board for the hand rail rather than a true hand rail that can be easily gripped to prevent falls. The B & B is on a corner & faces the side street. The gift shop faces a well traveled 2 lane rural road, so it's not a location for a Romantic Get Away but suited us well as a base while we visited the area. (We ran the fan on the a.c. to cover the traffic sound.)

3 breakfasts all tasty and all generous. Good variety. Dave was very accommodating and helpful.

Hard water makes cleanup a bit more challenging but is not a big issue.