Hotels in Shelter Island, New York
Provide your desired dates to access the latest pricing and special offers for hotels
Welcome to Shelter Island, the hidden gem of New York's North Fork, where relaxation flows as easily as the waters of Peconic Bay. This charming hamlet, with its sleepy vibe and exclusive retreat ambiance, draws you into a world far removed from hustle and bustle. When it comes to hotels, you’ll find cozy inns and luxurious lodges that cater to every trendsetting traveler. Imagine waking up in a beautifully appointed guest room adorned with maritime motifs, sipping your morning coffee while the gentle sea breeze rolls through your window. Whether you’re here for an intimate weekend getaway or an adventurous family escape, Shelter Island's hotels are as welcoming as a warm hug from an old friend.
As you explore the magical shores of Shelter Island, you’ll discover accommodations that capture the essence of quintessential island life. Many hotels boast stunning water views, providing the perfect backdrop for your retreat. Picture unwinding at the hotel pool after a day of kayaking or biking through the lush landscapes of the island’s nature preserves. Many establishments also offer optional perks such as complimentary bicycles, spa services, and farm-to-table dining experiences that elevate your stay from ordinary to extraordinary. With a focus on relaxation and rejuvenation, every hotel reflects the island’s inviting atmosphere, making it easy to settle in and let go of your worries.
Of course, what would a stay in Shelter Island be without your taste buds getting a proper vacation too? Delicious dining options abound in local hotels, where chefs whip up culinary masterpieces using locally sourced seafood and farm-fresh produce. Whether you’re dining al fresco under twinkling lights or cozied up next to a fireplace inside the hotel bistro, the local flavors will leave you craving more. So, pack your bags and set sail for Shelter Island—where every hotel promises a unique adventure and an unforgettable retreat filled with charm, tranquility, and a touch of luxury!
Best Hotels in Shelter Island
Rams Head Inn
Spa/Wellness packages
Restaurant
Beachfront
Experience the charm of Rams Head Inn, a cozy 2-star hotel located just 2.4mi from the Shelter Island city center. Enjoy a beachfront oasis with free private beach access and water sports facilities, perfect for families and pet lovers alike. Indulge in our spa/wellness packages, savor delicious meals at our on-site restaurant, and unwind on the sun deck or terrace with stunning garden views. Additionally, we offer free Wi-Fi and private parking, making your stay both convenient and enjoyable. Rams Head Inn combines comfort and leisure, providing an exceptional getaway compared to other hotels in the area.
Cities nearby
Cities nearby