New York hotels. Best hotels in New York, United States

Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York

Provide your desired dates to access the latest pricing and special offers for hotels

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Nestled on the idyllic Shelter Island Heights, where serene landscapes meet quaint charm, travelers are in for an unforgettable experience when considering local hotel options. With varied accommodations ranging from historic inns to modern lodges, you can find the perfect spot that suits your personal style and budget. The warmth of the locals and the beauty of the surroundings make this destination an oasis for relaxation, adventure, or a romantic getaway. Picture waking up to the soothing sounds of nature, enjoying breakfast on a private balcony, and setting off to explore the enchanting beaches and charming shops that give Shelter Island its unique character.

For those who love hospitality with a twist, some of the boutique hotels in the area offer themed rooms that transport guests to different eras or cultures. Think vibrant 1960s decor, or coastal chic aesthetics that invite you to kick back, relax, and embrace the island vibe. Many establishments boast top-notch amenities such as refreshing swimming pools, calming spas, and dining options that feature local seafood caught fresh daily. When evening falls, guests can gather by fire pits under the starry sky, sharing stories and laughter with fellow travelers, creating lasting memories that are sure to inch their way into tales of wanderlust.

One of the more intriguing aspects of staying in hotels on Shelter Island Heights is the opportunity to tour various historic sites, like the renowned Shelter Island Heights Historic District. Steps away from your cozy lodging, rich history and culture await exploration. Dive into the region's fascinating past and discover the stories behind the beautifully preserved Victorian houses. Whether you’re indulging in a leisurely breakfast at your hotel’s cafe before venturing out, or returning in the evening to unwind at a chic rooftop bar, you’ll feel the unique blend of hospitality that makes Shelter Island Heights truly special. So pack your bags, grab your sunglasses, and prepare for an unforgettable adventure surrounded by breathtaking beauty and warm connections!

Best Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Property building in The Pridwin Hotel

The Pridwin Hotel

Restaurant

Beachfront

Private beach area

Nestled in the serene Shelter Island Heights, The Pridwin Hotel shines as a 3-star gem, just 1.4mi from the city center. With its exclusive beachfront and private beach area, guests enjoy free access to the sun, sand, and water sports facilities. Unwind in the outdoor swimming pool or explore the complimentary fitness center, tennis court, and soothing sauna. The hotel offers a variety of dining options, including a restaurant and bar, perfect for unwinding after a day of fun. With free private parking and a dedicated 24-hour front desk, The Pridwin Hotel promises an unforgettable, hassle-free getaway.