The staff were awesome! They gave me a room upgrade at no extra charge, as I stayed in February, a slow month. They started the fireplace in the library, just for me, so I could enjoy breakfast in a warm and cozy atmosphere. Nice gas fireplace in my room, too.

The check-in time of 2-4 pm seemed a bit unrealistic. I had to make an appointment for check in after those hours. And the $25 penalty for check-in after 9 pm, which is stated in the website, seemed a bit unfair. But the staff were great about keeping in touch via text message.

The inn is classic old New England. There is a public sitting room and outside seating. Although we didn’t actually eat at the restaurant, the menu looked great. Staff throughout the establishment, including The Side Door, could not have been friendlier. The Side Door was really hopping when we stayed. Florence Griswold Museum is right across the street. Plus, if you like colonial era homes there is a self guided walking tour available of Old Lyme.

Although it’s near vicinity to I-95 makes it really convenient to get around, when you sit outside, you do hear the highway noise. That is not true when you are in your room. Our room was quiet and peaceful.

We enjoyed our stay. It is quiet in the evenings unless you are in the bar with the hiking club. The price was quite a bit more than we ever pay but it was close to family and it was lovely. I almost cancelled to stay at a hotel for half the price. The drinks are not cheap in the bar. Perhaps a discount for those that are staying at the Inn. We had muffins and juice one morning and they were tasty. The staff are wonderful and outgoing. We are use to a softer bed but loved the king size room in the corner - #3. Thank you!

The price and the cost of drinks. A fridge in the room would be lovely also.

A beautiful in directly opposite from the Florence Griswold museum and the art association. A 10 min walk down Lyme street yields some beautiful houses to look at (although there isn't a centre of town so much). The inn has nice lounge spaces to hang out in.

It was a lovely stay and everything was as advertised. The bathroom doesn't have shelf space to put your toiletries but it does everything you need. Old Lyme itself wasn't as exciting for us, but nearby Essex was a nice place to go for a little stroll.

Charming atmosphere, friendly and helpful staff, loved the Jazz brunch…the owners were present lovely and welcoming. We have stayed there many times over the years. The dining was excellent and cozy bar on site is very relaxing. 5stars everything🥰

The only thing I missed was not being able to walk out the door and take a brisk walk each day..no sidewalks🙈

A special place to stay. A lovely old inn in charming Old Lyme. The staff were super personable, the room was lovely and comfortable, and the breakfast was reasonably priced and tasty.

Nothing not to like! If it were a little less expensive, I could stay there more often ;-)

We loved the jazz at brunch and the night before. The food and service was excellent. The rooms cozy and warm.

Only one thing. The room needed better lighting. The bulbs in the lamps were different. One a bright white and the other very dim. I know it is very minor and you are rolling your eyes. But I am an interior designer and lighting makes or breaks a room.

We love this place! We came back after years especially to fresh up memories since the time we used to live in the area. The owner of the place are just wonderful and the night with Jazz in The side door ( next to place) was the reason we came to this very unique place. The Jazz Brunch on Sunday morning we enjoyed a lot too! The rooms are lovely and you feel a little bit like coming home. We have to come back during winter to light up the 🔥 fire in the room.

The breakfast in the morning is just muffins and the or coffee. We would prefer some toast, butter and Marmelade, but that was just the only small thing I personally missed.

The staff was upbeat and helpful, and the Inn is an historic and lovely treasure. On one late afternoon of my stay, an acoustic guitar soloist played on the outside patio for happy hour. I really enjoyed his music.

The bathroom could use some counter space, and the windows did not stay open on their own. I like fresh air at night.

Definitely the beauty of the place and the service. Why go to New England to stay in a typical hotel room when you can stay at a historic mansion impeccably maintained? One night we got back very late and wanted some coffee. The manager personally took care of us and a waitress got us a delicious espresso and a latte. At no charge!!! That I call great hospitality.