Location was great. Food was great pool and music was just right.

The only downfall to the trip was the fire alarm went off at 5 AM for about eight minutes loud. Unfortunately the last time I went away in Miami this happened as well. I was very surprised this happened at this hotel although they fixed it they didn’t have much to say when I brought it up to the clerk it was as if it was not a big deal. We were exhausted the next day, I think this was a big no no I needs to be avoided

Spectacular setting, with excellent dining and service. Got a gorgeous water view room with a generous Booking.com discount. Lovely room, awesome bathrobe and linens. Very laid back atmosphere. The building is the old Montauk Yacht Club, and retains the historic features, with great old photos. The marina area is a beautiful walk. All in all, a very nice surprise.

No complaints.

Location was great, rode hotel bikes to the lighthouse Quiet time of year - was very peaceful and relaxing Room was upgraded - beautiful. All staff were friendly and helpful with suggestions Had the brick oven pizza was very good

Received amazing service from Maureen. She was welcoming and beyond wonderful!! Thank you so much! Will plan to go back to the hotel when visiting Montauk again ! The property is so clean. The hotel ground is serene and secluded. I had the best sleep ever living in a hotel.

Everything! The service was excellent, the rooms were spacious with a beautiful water view. The staff were very attentive, it was easy to get around the property, and it’s close to town.

Nothing. Can’t wait to go back!

the ambience and fantastic. very peaceful surrounding. The staff were well mannered and the private beach setting was awesome! swimming pool was super clean and opened upon request.

sadly the restaurant was closed throughout our stay.

Beautiful! Super clean! Loved there was a restaurant and bar on premise.

The view we had of the back of an addition. :( a beautiful view obscured by maybe a newer addition on the building.

Location, room ,amenities were great

We asked for a late check out and we’re not given one It’s very expensive for a 4:00 check in and 11:00 check out - not even a full day of having the room

Absolutely loved the hotel! The decor was beautiful, the staff was helpful and very friendly and I loved my room. I do plan to return next year.

They should have more options for food.

Our view was exceptional. Really made the whole experience. The decor and design of hotel was beautiful and everything was clean and chic. Loved all the extra amenities even though we didn't get a chance to utilize them because we were only in town for the night. Will definitely be back! :)

Room was a little small for 4 people but otherwise everything was amazing. We ordered room service an hour before close and someone took our order and then realized it was taken at the wrong Gurney's location? Not sure how that happened and not upset at the confusion but just wanted to let you know for future guests who might find this a problem.