The location was great with good coffee shops and eateries and Shelter Island all within walking distance. The room was very clean and airy. The bed was so comfortable and the toiletries provided were great too. The hotel is small and welcoming and the staff were friendly and helpful.

Sadly the restaurant is closed on Sunday and Monday nights (the 2 nights I stayed) so there was not much going on in the hotel whilst I was there - it was very quiet. I was told that it’s a great place for cocktails (when open!). It would also have been great to have some comfortable loungers by the pool rather than just upright chairs.

Great property, beautifully renovated and nice style with lots of lively details. Comfortable spaces.

Lack of iron and ironing board and coffee maker in the rooms was disappointing. I wouldn’t usually miss an iron but travelling for work sometimes requires it. I’d recommend coffee makers in the rooms.

The Pearl is in a great location, has a wonderful free breakfast of bagels and yogurt / granola, and has a cute little courtyard with a pool. It was calm, quiet, and a great stay!

There was music playing in the courtyard til ~10pm, but they shut it off after that. And there was limited parking, we had to find some on the street. Also the rooms were slightly musty. But all around, great stay!

lovely, room and furnishing, good soundproofing, comfortable mattress helpful receptionist, good, included breakfast with nice fruit, beautiful, outdoor pool and restaurant

water pressure in shower very low, even for California, bed too low to floor, road in front of hotel seemed dangerous to cross on foot or bicycle (which I did not rent) due to speeding cars. A stop sign given location of hotel in relation to harbor, would be sensible. No apparent assistance for carrying luggage up stairs

- Beautifully renovated vintage motel with a very stylish and modern touch in the interiors. - 100% bed linen and comfortable mattresses - great selection of restaurants nearby - AMAZING healthy breakfast (chia and fresh berries and other items) included in the price when we visited

Nothing - everything was perfect!

Convenient location, great staff and clean.

The key cards were a pain. We had to have them reprogrammed just about every time. After the first time, and advice from the staff, we kept them in separate areas away from phones, and STILL every time we had to come down to have them re done.

The room was cozy, the ameneties were lovely, the breakfast was SO good, and the stazff could not have been more friendly. We wish we could have had some more time there to enjoy the bar and the pool-- it looked lovely!

It was all really great! i would stay there again.

the vibe is awesome. very cool retro motel. awesome bar. food choices are limited but the food was outstanding

bed frame was really noisy. creaked everytime you turn over. but mattress and pillows are super comfy

The room was very nice and the staff were extremely helpful and friendly. The hotel was also easy to reach and in walking distance of the sea.

Slightly more facilities (mini fridge in the room, breakfast in the restaurant) would have been nice, but we managed very well without

Second time at The Pearl. It’s lovely! It’s location is perfect, enough things to do nearby without being crazy busy. And the design/ decoration feels so good! The non-corporate experience. Personnel another plus, smart, present and helpful.